"Eeney, Meeney, Miney, Ed" is the first episode of Season 2 and the twenty-seventh episode of Ed, Edd n Eddy. In this episode, Eddy tricks Ed into thinking that Edd is a lizard man who is turning the Kids into animal-human hybrids. Ed believes this lie and he soon becomes terrified that he may be the next one to be turned into an insect.
The newest scam Eddy has in mind is a miniature golf course that Edd has spent the whole morning working on. Unfortunately, when the time comes to test it out, Eddy can't get a shot off, and Ed's swing sends the club sailing straight through the middle of the amazing mechanical obstacle Edd constructed to be the centerpiece of the course. While Edd examines the machine to see what, if anything, can be done, Ed questions Eddy about how Double D got so smart. An offhand comment by Eddy to the effect that Edd isn't human sparks Ed's imagination, and Eddy is all too willing to weave a tale of a deep underground cavern, a mad scientist, and crossbreeding experiments that created "The Lizardman". Seeing that Ed is hooked, Eddy mentions that Edd hides his gills under his hat, and Ed runs off to try and touch the gills.
When Ed tries to feel under Edd's hat, he is quickly rebuffed. Soon, a timer goes off in Edd's pocket, and he notes that it's time for him to check on an experiment of his. Ed runs to follow, but Eddy stops him, pulling him back and saying that they're not alone. Ed notices Sarah and Jimmy playing and agrees with this statement, only for Eddy to contradict him and say that Edd turned Sarah into a praying mantis and Jimmy into a stinkbug. Eddy then leads Ed to Rolf's place, where Rolf is working, and says that Edd turned Rolf into a picnic ant. A fly then lands on Ed's nose, and Ed prepares to crush it before Eddy stops him, saying that it's another piece of Double D's handiwork. This spurs Ed to run off, suddenly needing to find the Lizardman.
Edd is working in his garage, taking notes on a complicated experiment, when Ed finds him. Edd notices Ed's strange behavior and remarks on it only for Ed to sniff his skin and declare him not of this earth. This worries Edd greatly, and he checks his breath; finding it foul, he runs inside to brush his teeth. Ed's imagination is now in full gear, and he says that he saw Edd's tail. Eddy, barely able to keep from bursting into laughter, warns Ed that the tail is dangerous, but the real dangers are the laser beams shot from Edd's eyes and hands him a mirror to defend himself with. The two then head upstairs to confront the monster and find him brushing his teeth in his bathroom. Edd turns around, foaming at the mouth, and starts to approach as the lights strobe on him. Eddy is of course controlling the lights, and he snickers at Ed's reaction before calling for Ed to use the mirror. Ed comes up with a novel use for it quickly, and sticks it into Edd's mouth, wedging it open, and then runs away, slamming the door on the bathroom. He breathes a sigh of relief and tells Eddy that everything's okay...except Eddy is nowhere to be found. Suddenly, Eddy's screams split the air.
Ed rushes around the corner to find Eddy's clothes laid out on the floor. He laments as Edd comes up behind him and asks if Eddy is running around naked again. Terrified, Ed demands an antidote, then asks if he's all alone. Panicked, he declares that he is hungry and makes a break for it as Edd runs after him, offering various foods. Outside, Ed suddenly stops, as in front of him is a vision of utter beauty. This vision invites the two to a pool party. Edd readily accepts the invitation, but Ed is slow to accept. When Nazz and Edd request that he join them, Ed finally gives up, as it's no fun being the last human–and then asks to be a bumblebee, to the confusion of both. While the three walk off, Eddy is in the upstairs of Edd's house, wearing a bucket over his body and using his fingers to walk. Coachroach Eddy is complimenting himself on his fine scheme when he comes to the stairs and falls down them. At the bottom, he can see Ed and Edd following Nazz to a party, much to his annoyance, as he wasn't asked to come.
At the barbecue, everyone is having fun. Kevin is grilling hot dogs, Rolf has brought a ham for himself, and Jonny is having a fun time watching the festivities. Ed is still thinking that Edd is a mutant, though, and has chosen yet another transformation: a mosquito. He wanders off, and a whisper reaches his ears. Following it, he finds Eddy, who wants the bucket off, but Ed, being oblivious, decides to take Eddy to "his people". Ed picks Eddy up to show him off, but Eddy is swiftly mistaken for a bug and, after being bashed around by Nazz, mistaken for desert by Rolf, and hearing general cries to squash the bug, hides in the cellar.
Rolf, noticing this, takes off his shoe to use as a weapon and tells the others to follow him into Nazz's basement. While Jimmy, Sarah, Jonny, and Plank bow out of the expedition, the rest go along, not even deterred by Ed's confusing cry "Let the transformation begin!" In the basement, Edd's suggestion that they find a light switch is disregarded, as Kevin shines his flashlight around the basement floor. Sensing something, Rolf suggests that Kevin shine his "moonbox" in a certain direction, and a few seconds after it reaches the spot, Eddy leaps out right into the light. Eddy hides behind a desk, but Rolf leaps over it and begins whacking the "bug" with his shoe. Eventually, Edd finds the light, and Rolf realizes that what he thought was a bug was really Eddy. Ed says that Edd turned Eddy into a cockroach, and when accusatory stares are leveled at him, Edd tells the truth: he really hasn't a clue. Bored, the rest of the kids climb back upstairs while Edd helps Ed free Eddy from the bucket. Rolf and Kevin stop at the top of the stairs, with Rolf wondering if the trio are truly from this world; Kevin denies this, saying they're from the Land of the Dorks, and turns the lights off.
Ed[finds Eddy's clothes lying on Edd's floor]: "Oh no! Not Eddy! Take me, Lizard Man!" Edd: [finds Eddy's clothes on the ground and becomes worried] "Why are Eddy's clothes lying on my floor? Is he running around naked again?"
Rolf: [picks Eddy up from his shoe] "Huh? This is no bug." Nazz: "Is that Eddy?" Kevin: [excited] "Hit him again!"
Edd: [seeing the time in his hourglass] "Ooh! My cocoons need tending!" Eddy: [to Ed] "What'd I tell ya?"
Ed: "Am I the only human left? I am alone! I am hungry!" Edd: "Wait, Ed! I can make you a sandwich."
Nazz: [inviting Ed and Edd to her barbecue] "Lots of food." Edd: "Yes! Join us Ed." Nazz & Edd: [in unison] "Join us, Ed! Join us, Ed! Join us, Ed!" Ed: "OKAY, I GIVE UP! It's no fun being the last human. So can I be a bumblebee?"
Edd: "Jonny, have you seen Ed?" [Ed pokes Edd on the back of his head several times] "Oh, hello, Ed." Ed: "I picked a mosquito. As I am ready to be transformed and join your colony!" Sarah: [eating her hot dog] "What an idiot." Ed: [imitating a mosquito] "Buzz, buzz, buzz." Eddy[whispering] "Psst! Ed, come here." [Ed goes over to where he heard Eddy and then he sees Eddy in a bucket] Ed: "Eddy! You look good for a cockroach." Eddy: "Knock it off, just get this bucket off me!" Ed: [picking up Eddy] "Let me take you to your people." Eddy: "No, wait!" Nazz: "Hi, Ed. Would you like a-" [panics upon noticing Eddy as a "bug"] "BUG!" Ed: [startled] "Huh? Where?! Get it off!"
Rolf: [looking at Edd & Ed pulling Eddy out from the bucket] "Are they from this planet?" Kevin: [shakes head] "Nope. They're from the Land of the Dorks." Edd: "Can someone tell me what's going on here?" [Kevin turns off the lights] "Well?" Ed: "Basement!" Eddy: "Foot!" Ed: [disgusted sound]
Eddy: "What planet are you from?" Ed: [hugging Eddy] "I come in peace, Eddy!"
The golf machine monster's teeth change in number during beginning of the episode.
Look closely at the golf machine; after Edd turns it on for the first time, the machine has two menacing, intimidating eyebrows, but right before the golf club that Ed threw hits it, the eyebrows are gone.
Rolf was shown with four toes in this episode, but all the other characters are shown to have three.
When Ed says, "Whoa, Rolf's pretty good for a picnic ant", the bottom part of Nazz's shirt changes color.
In Eddy's golf scam, the golf clubs were, surprisingly, real golf clubs, unlike many of his scams involving almost everything made of improvised objects.
When Edd turns on the light switch to Nazz's basement, he flips a switch on the bottom floor of the basement, but when Kevin turns off the lights, he does so with a switch at the top of the basement. However, it's entirely possible the basement has two switches.